
Electricity
Coal retirements partly offset by natural gas’s rising prominence
Climate Action Index: Electricity | 2019 = base year
-
Coal phase-out has driven sector progress: Coal-fired generation has fallen since 2019, led by Alberta’s completed coal phase-out.1 Retiring legacy coal plants seems to be the sector’s most effective decarbonization lever to date.
-
Year-on-year action gains are narrowing as the cheapest abatement—coal switching—slows. The index continues to grow on sustained investment inflows, falling emissions intensity, and progressive additions of energy storage capacity.
-
Grid decarbonization has progressed despite policy uncertainty. Electricity sector emissions have declined since 2019 as coal generation has fallen and renewables have grown.2 3 Investment tax credits supported continued grid expansion, though an expanded role for natural gas and possible changes to the Clean Electricity Regulations cloud the longer-term outlook.
-
Energy storage deployment is unlocking renewable grid integration. Utility-scale battery projects reached commercial operation in 2025, providing critical flexibility to accommodate variable renewable generation.4 Combined with renewable capacity additions, storage deployment can address a fundamental technical barrier to deeper decarbonization and support grid resilience during the transition. The Oneida energy storage project in Ontario drove the index’s rise, with Alberta’s market adding on storage as well. As much as 2.1 gigawatt-hours of energy storage came online in 2025, a major increase over the 0.1 gigawatt-hours of storage deployed in 2024.5
-
Sectoral investment commitment remains strong, despite uncertainty. Recent Canada Infrastructure Bank commitments—a $206 million loan for Nova Scotia’s Mersey River wind farm6 and $54 million towards the Wasoqonatl transmission intertie linking Nova Scotia and New Brunswick (bringing its total commitment to $285 million)7—demonstrate continued public support to low-carbon electricity infrastructure.
-
AI infrastructure is arriving faster than clean power supply can be built, repositioning natural gas’s role in the energy transition. The International Energy Agency’s projections indicate that global data centre electricity consumption will more than double to roughly 945 TWh by 20308 – slightly more than Japan’s entire electricity consumption today. In Canada, Meta’s $13 billion, 1GW data centre in Sturgeon County, Alta., powered by the $4.6 billion dedicated natural gas plant, is expected to consume as much electricity as 800,000 homes.9 The company has also committed to matching its consumption with renewable energy investments. According to the IEA, renewables and natural gas will be key energy sources powering AI data centre buildout, though grid expansion remains a bottleneck.
Case Study
Metering the Island
The Challenge
Electricity demand in Prince Edward Island has risen sharply over the past decade. Maritime Electric, which supplies about 90% of the province’s electricity customers, saw its annual system peak climb 60% between 2014 and 2023, with a further 32% increase forecast from 2024 – 2033.1
Most options for covering peak demands, especially in winter, require large electricity projects in the country’s smallest province. It would take years to construct as well as add costs to the rate base—the province had to find additional ways to address how to cover the peaks, and the new wave of demand it faces.
That matters in a province where on-Island generation is dominated by wind and solar, with less than one per cent coming from fossil-fuelled sources, an emissions intensity of 7.2 grams of GHG per kilowatt-hour, the third lowest of any province or territory.2
However, the majority of electricity consumed in PEI is imported from New Brunswick, which generates its electricity from a mix of nuclear, fossil fuels, and hydroelectricity.
Roughly two-thirds of PEI’s electricity is imported from New Brunswick. NB’s supply is over 67% non-emitting but carries a higher emissions intensity of 226 g GHG/kWh, so PEI’s overall supply mix is more carbon-intensive than its on-Island generation alone.3
The Idea
One option works on demand rather than supply: smart meters, also known as advanced metering infrastructure (AMI).
The technology is well established elsewhere in Canada: British Columbia, Alberta, Ontario and Quebec completed their rollouts years ago, and Natural Resources Canada put smart meters at roughly 82% of all meters in Canada by the end of 2018.4
Unlike the meters they replace, AMI meters record consumption at short intervals through the day and communicate it back over a network, which shows the utility when demand peaks rather than only how much a customer used in a month.5
The Island Regulatory and Appeals Commission (IRAC) approved a province-wide advanced metering and customer information project in October 2024, supported by $19 million in federal funding through Natural Resources Canada’s Smart Renewables and Electrification Pathways Program. Installation began in November 2025 and is scheduled to reach the whole Island by 2027. Around 70% of North American utilities already run this technology.6
The Obstacle
Even in a small province like PEI, widespread deployment of AMI technology will take time. About 34,000 smart meters had been installed as of July, with roughly 60,000 to go. However, those will take longer as they will be in rural areas and require more travel. The work isn’t expected to be finished until next summer.7
Pushing demand shifts can take even longer. Smart meters provide information that allows the introduction of time-of-use pricing, which can encourage customers to reduce electricity use during peak periods. But time-of-use pricing requires a regulatory application, and Maritime Electric has said it will investigate rates after it has collected enough data to build a case—a process that could take several years.8
Changing behaviour is difficult. Incentives to change habits may not be enough. Case in point: in Ontario where the auditor general found that the difference between on-peak and off-peak electricity rates had not been significant enough to encourage a change in consumption.
Costs need to be contained. Ontario’s auditor general also found that the province’s smart metering project was $1 billion over budget. Ontario had also set up a $249-million data centre to collect, analyze and store electricity consumption data—but most distribution companies ended up using their own systems.ix That duplication, and the cost overruns, were passed along to ratepayers.
The Insight
A small province can move quicker. When Ontario was installing its smart meters a decade ago, it was dealing with dozens of local distribution companies. That came with its own challenges—40 of 73 distribution companies sought extensions because of operational or technical problems.10 PEI’s smaller size has proven to be an advantage with fewer stakeholders involved.
PEI can learn from other regions in the country. Ontario’s auditor general found shortcomings in the way smart meter data was processed. As it collects data on electricity usage, PEI can learn from other province’s experiences and thoughtfully set rates if it wants to move the needle on demand.
Smart meters need to be deployed in a smart way. They work best when paired with tools that make behaviour changes easy—such as automated EV charging, or time-of-use rates that are clear and easy to understand.
BC Hydro introduced the Peak Saver program, which provides customers who help reduce demand during peak hours an annual reward of $50 or $100, depending on income. As of last year, more than 130,000 customers had earned rewards by reducing demand, and have provided capacity savings of about 34 megawatts—the equivalent of charging around 40,000 electric vehicles.11
Smart meters need to be deployed in a smart way. They work best when paired with tools that make behaviour changes easy
Climate Action Index
-
Canada Energy Regulator, Canada’s Energy Future, 2026, Current Measures Scenario
-
Absolute emissions from the Canadian Climate Institute’s Early Estimate of National Emissions (EENE)
-
Grid emissions intensity calculated based on electricity sector emissions from Canadian Climate Institute’s Early Estimate of National Emissions (EENE) and Statistics Canada Table 25-10-0015-01 (formerly CANSIM 127-0002). Last emissions actual in 2024; 2025 – 2026 values projected.
-
Oneida Energy Storage (Northland Power), commercial operation May 2025.
-
BloombergNEF Energy Storage Assets database.
-
CIB supporting First Nations in bringing clean power to New Brunswick and Nova Scotia.
-
AI to double data centre power and water consumption by 2030, UN researchers say
-
NEWS RELEASE – Meta makes historic investment in Alberta | Sturgeon County
-
Change in absolute electricity sector emissions, 2019 – 2026. 2019 figure from Environment and Climate Change Canada, National Inventory Report. 2026 figure is a projection from ECCC’s published emissions projections (With Measures Scenario). Reduction is an estimate.
-
Change in electricity-sector emissions intensity (emissions per unit of generation), 2019 – 2026. Emissions from ECCC National Inventory Report. 2026 figure from ECCC’s With Measures Scenario projections. Generation figures from Statistics Canada, Table 25-10-0015-01, “Electric power generation, monthly generation by type of electricity” (2026 annualized from available monthly data). Reduction figure is an estimate.
Case Study
-
PEI Energy Strategy, p. 6, citing Environment and Climate Change Canada, National Inventory Report 2025, Tables A13-3 and A13-5.
-
ibid
-
ibid
-
CBC News, Maritime Electric installing data collectors on poles as part of transition to smart meters
-
CBC News, Maritime Electric installing data collectors on poles as part of transition to smart meters
-
Peak performance: BC Hydro customers can earn more by using less when it matters most
Click here to view our methodology