Skip to main content

Buildings

Heat-pump adoption emerges as bright spot

  • Policy pullbacks dragged the index down. The federal consumer carbon price and British Columbia’s carbon tax were wound down. Vancouver paused its carbon limit rules, while Ontario’s green building standards have created a “degree of uncertainty” to implement the Toronto Green Standard, according to Toronto City.1 Combined with broader uncertainty about climate policies and some resistance to sustainability commitments, it appears building owners are prioritizing investments that cut actual operating costs—such as energy efficiency—over high-profile “green” pledges that don’t deliver savings.

  • Annual capital flows is at around $2 billion. That’s little changed since 2021 and falls short of the $5.4 billion needed for Canada to meet its net-zero goals by 2050, according to an earlier report from RBC.2 Federal Deep Retrofit Accelerator Initiative (DRAI) support has built a pipeline of retrofit studies, but most applicants appear to be waiting for the next cycle, widening the gap between identified opportunities and committed capital.3

  • Residential heat pumps are a bright spot. Adoption reached an estimated 9–10% of housing stock,4 and the commercial frontier is opening via hybrid systems such as dual-fuel rooftop units that allow warehouse and open-air retail owners to reduce emissions without committing to full electrification.

  • Building owners are taking a more cautious, operational savings approach. With broad investment uncertainty in real estate, climate efforts seem to be shifting back to energy efficiency and delivering utility cost savings to find a way to drive net operating income growth. DRAI funding helped many more buildings get assessed.

  • Utility efficiency programs have scaled up. Demand-side spending has risen in recent years and there are strong, long-term funding commitments for efficiency programs in Ontario and Quebec. These programs line up with the operational-savings incentives owners are now prioritizing. Durable gains like the British Columbia and Quebec provincial zero-carbon codes, the federal Green Buildings Strategy, and independent oversight remain in force. New federal model-code GHG limits were set in 2025 but are non-binding until provinces adopt them.

Case Study

Choice Properties owns and manages approximately 700 assets across Canada. Many of these properties are open-air shopping centres and warehouses that rely on rooftop units to heat and cool individual tenant spaces. When the company committed to net-zero emissions across its portfolio by 20501, rooftop heating equipment emerged as one of its largest opportunities to reduce emissions.

Whole-building deep retrofits were not practical for much of this portfolio due to the nature of the building systems. One property can have many rooftop units of different ages, each serving a separate tenant space. The units do not fail in unison, and replacing them all at once would be costly, disruptive and difficult to fund within the confines of existing tenant arrangements.

Ariel Feldman, Assistant Vice-President, Capital Projects, Choice Properties, said the company was trying to understand how to drive down emissions in a way that was technically feasible, cost-effective and met payback thresholds.

Choice shifted its perspective on capital planning and emissions reduction targets. Instead of asking how to undertake a deep retrofit at every property, it looked for incremental opportunities each time ordinary equipment reached the end of its life.

Dual-fuel rooftop units offered a practical solution. They combine an electric heat pump with a conventional gas heating system. The heat pump provides most of the heating during the year, while gas remains available during very cold weather or when electricity prices are high.2 This approach aims to reduce natural gas use without requiring a building to be fully electrified at once.

Juhee Oh, Director, Sustainability and Climate, Choice Properties, said that the company shifted from individual building transition plans to a portfolio-wide equipment strategy. Depending on the region, the heat pump can meet 80% to 95% of annual heating needs. In provinces with relatively clean electricity, we estimate heating emissions could fall by roughly 70% to 80%, alongside an energy-efficiency improvement of about 20%, Oh said.

With the technical solution identified, Choice mapped out the business case for dual fuel rooftop units. Each replacement must work as a capital investment, competing for funding with other projects across the portfolio. Choice compares the incremental cost of a dual-fuel unit with a conventional replacement, then considers utility prices, incentives, expected savings, electrical capacity, installation costs and the payback period.

The economics vary across Canada. Choice said that it modelled early pilots and found an escalating federal carbon price, which strengthened the case for electrification. The company found that after the carbon price was removed, local utility rates and incentives became even more important. A project that works in one province may not produce the same savings in another.

Ownership and leases add another layer of complexity. Choice does not control the rooftop equipment on every building. Where it does, the project must work within the existing financial relationship between owner and tenant rather than depend on lease amendments. The team reviews who pays for equipment, energy and maintenance, and whether costs and savings are sufficiently aligned to proceed.

Timing matters too. If a rooftop unit fails unexpectedly, replacement becomes an emergency and a conventional gas unit may be easier to source. Choice identifies aging equipment early, allowing time to analyze the project, apply for incentives, coordinate with tenants and suppliers, and order equipment. Proactive planning to allow for longer equipment lead times can also reduce the cost premium of dual fuel over conventional units.

These obstacles do not stop the program; they are the work required to find the win-win, said Feldman. Among units nearing replacement and under its control, Choice has been able to proceed with dual-fuel heat pumps in about 70% of cases.

The big breakthrough was that Choice began planning around equipment availability, instead of the mindset of a capital project with set timelines.

Choice included rooftop-unit replacements in its 2025-to-2027 climate action roadmap and completed equipment replacements covering approximately 800,000 square feet in the first year.3

The company is now measuring operating costs, energy and emissions performance to refine assumptions for future projects.

The experience found that portfolio decarbonization does not always depend on one major retrofit. Large reductions can come from making a better decision when ordinary equipment needs replacing.

With early planning and a systematic review of the economics, leases and equipment specifications, owners can overcome the obstacles. Repeated across a large portfolio, routine capital decisions can become a scalable path to meaningful emissions reductions.