As part of RBC Thought Leadership’s deep dive into the Creative economy, Disruptors podcast host Trinh Theresa Do talked to Josie Fung, executive director of I-Think, a non-profit organization based at the Rotman School of Management in Toronto. I-Think partners with educators to foster creative problem-solving skills in students.
How would you define creativity?
What we’ve seen, having worked with hundreds of thousands of students, is that creativity is about having insights, seeing something that someone hasn’t seen before and doing something with it.
Does it have to be relevant to the ultimate stakeholder?
Absolutely. Creativity is often driven by a need that is unmet. For your creativity or idea to have value, you have to meet that need.
Integrative thinking is a guiding methodology for I-Think. What is it?
Integrative thinking is this idea developed by [former Rotman dean] Roger Martin. When we have to make a tough decision, we’re often stuck between two ideas. A or B? Integrative thinking says instead of choosing, we’re going to create a new idea out of elements of those two ideas. On a practical level, there is no one way to do things and our job is to be constantly searching for new ways to approach problems.
How has Canada’s education system historically treated creativity?
When I was growing up, you went to art class to be creative. But now I think education is seeing that students are amazingly creative and our job isn’t to make them more creative. It’s to keep their creativity alive. About 10 years ago, Ontario came out with play-based kindergarten. That was a big signal to the system. We’re starting with kindergarten, but how do you infuse it throughout the system?
There are still people who see a divide between creative and noncreative fields. What do you think is stopping them from accepting that creativity can be useful everywhere?
Many of us went to school believing our job was to find the one right answer. And if you don’t get that right answer, you’re just wrong. Inherently, if you really want to be creative, you have to be unafraid that there are many possible answers that haven’t been discovered yet.
So as educators, what should they do to remove that fear?
One of the key ingredients for great creativity is diversity, meaning different people, different viewpoints. The second thing is how do we stop focusing on evaluation as the marker of success? What I hear from students is that by the time they get to our course, ‘I have this opportunity to see things in a totally new light. But I’ve never been asked to do that before.’ They keep asking us what the right answer should look like. But when I’m giving them a real world problem that doesn’t have an answer, there’s no right answer.
How do we get their voices more involved in those discussions?
It’s about creating spaces where we’re giving those real world problems that students can solve. It turns out that students have just as good ideas as the rest of us, the rest of us being adults. Sometimes even better.
How do we maintain that in these students when they enter the workforce and may be given even more constraints?
What we’ve seen is creativity actually thrives on constraints. When we started our work with I-Think we thought that if we gave students open reign on creating ideas, that would be the way forward. By giving a few more constraints, it actually helped channel their creativity.
Is that is that the problem in the corporate world? The lack of constraints?
The challenge of the corporate world is that we have this unwritten social contract that the things we are, are the ways they have to be. In this pandemic, for example, we have this conversation that is on one side ‘we should never return to the way things were before.’ And on the other side, ‘we want things to be as they were before.’ Could we not ask ourselves, what have we learned in this last year?It’s been hard. It’s been tough, but what have we learned?
We have to remember in the corporate environment is that there is no creativity department. And sometimes when there’s no creativity department, it feels like that’s no one’s job, but actually it’s everybody’s job. How do we think about every single job as being a creative job?
Where do you think Canada ranks among the most creative nations?
I think Canada’s up there. But we have some choices ahead. What makes us really successful is our diversity. We have in a given classroom, sometimes as many as 21 different languages being spoken. Just imagine the number of experiences these students have, the perspectives they’ve drawn from their families. The more we can bring that around the table, the more we have the opportunity to create new and amazing ideas.
What does that future Canada look like?
Future Canada is a place where there’s a hub of innovation. And instead of thinking about tech and innovation hubs localized in one geography, it’s a nation of creativity. It’s a nation that generates all sorts of ideas, that fuels the world.
So what is needed to enable every single job to be a creative job?
It starts with our leaders asking the question of ‘am I hiring people because I want them to do a specific task?’ Are we a world of just asking people to do tasks and, check things off a list? Or are we hiring people and supporting people so they’re solving the biggest problems in the world?
What do you think is preventing some leaders today from doing that?
Quite honestly, I think sometimes our incentive programs are flawed because we’re expecting people to generate outcomes on a very short term basis, whether that’s from the expectations of the street or because of how our incentive plans are built.
And do you think classrooms have a role to play in changing those incentive structures?
I think young people do a great job of is asking those questions. And the key is how do we have people listen to them? Because there’s so much of richness and value in what students have to say.
This interview was edited and condensed for clarity.
We spent months talking to experts about why creativity is a competitive advantage. Throughout this report, you’ll hear from them directly.
The new “it” skill
Welcome to the Soaring ‘20s, where creativity is the new “it” skill.
As Canada emerges from the COVID-19 crisis and enters a “two-dose summer,” we’re coming back together in workplaces, coffee shops and restaurant patios. There’s a palpable excitement in the air, and an opportunity: to harness this energy to rethink and rebuild in a new era of creativity.
The pandemic transformed the economy and disrupted every aspect of our lives. It also unleashed a remarkable wave of creativity.
If you peeked into the windows of Winnipeg’s Chaeban Ice Cream during the lockdown, you might have spotted owner Joseph Chaeban finally pursuing his childhood dream of making cheese. He’s now selling his artisanal creations to local restaurants, bakeries and grocery stores.
When sports stadiums went quiet, teenage entrepreneur Elias Andersen launched a new generation of audio technology from Thornbury, Ontario. Hear Me Cheer takes microphones in fans’ mobile devices and creates a real-time crowd atmosphere that’s been used in college football games and Major League Soccer.
Creativity is rising to the top, and not just in the usual places, like the arts or science and technology. We’re already seeing that between the first quarter of 2020 and the first quarter of 2021, employers began asking for more creative competencies in job postings, like critical thinking (up 37%) and flexibility (up 20%). The spike is particularly notable in healthcare, education, and sales and service—fields that were deeply impacted, and likely forever changed, by the pandemic.
“There is no commerce without creativity.”
—Daniel Lamarre, CEO of Cirque du Soleil
Every corner of our economy, from construction to retail, should be seen as a place for creativity to grow. If you think some sectors are too traditional to change—reconsider. Just look at how the agriculture sector has responded to the uncertainties of climate change, global trade spats and labour shortages: with vertical farming, where food grows in warehouses near city centres.
Now that people are once again gathering and mingling—the jet-fuel of creativity—this next decade is a prime time for creativity to flourish. The pandemic has shifted power to individuals, who can take advantage of an increasingly decentralized economy to work, shop, watch and learn from anywhere. Large cities, secondary centres and online platforms are suddenly on equal footing. There’s never been a better time to take a new idea and run with it.
The world was already on the cusp of a new creative era when the pandemic erupted. The key elements of the Fourth Industrial Revolution—automation and digitization—sparked an unprecedented opportunity to create. Individuals were free to take more risks, and businesses were more open to diverse ways of thinking and doing. Virtual reality, self-driving cars and remote surgery—all once the domain of science-fiction—were shepherded into reality.
LinkedIn data from more than 600 million professionals and 20 million jobs revealed creativity was the skill most in demand in 2019 and 2020.
Through our research, we are increasingly convinced that creativity is going to be a critical skill through the 2020s, as we re-emerge, re-build and re-invent, delivering ideas at a rate never seen before right across Canada.
The pandemic showed us that business doesn’t always proceed as usual. At the organizational level, firms are experiencing significant turnover. People are returning to different workplaces: either new ones, or ones that have radically changed since March 2020. It’s a unique moment in time, and it could slip away.
In this report, we talk with some of the most creative thinkers in Canada—business leaders, entrepreneurs, educators and artists—about Canada’s creative potential. We explore the growing demand for creative skills in key sectors of Canada’s economy, how different creative types deliver value—often in unexpected ways—and what actions should be taken to translate our country’s creativity into economic growth over the next decade.
There’s no time to waste, as we seek to solve some of the greatest challenges of our time: rebuilding downtowns, reimagining the delivery of healthcare and education, and tackling the climate crisis.
In Humans Wanted, a landmark 2018 report by RBC Thought Leadership and Economics, we examined how technology was disrupting the Canadian workforce, and identified the skills required for the jobs of the future.
The rise of artificial intelligence and automation mean routine and repetitive work is the most at-risk of disappearing, and even work in unexpected fields will be transformed. Our research showed the most highly valued skills are those not easily replicated by a machine—higher-function, cognitive activities from active listening to critical thinking and complex problem solving. Demand for these human, creative skills will only grow stronger.
Crisis drives creativity
This won’t be the first time crisis drives creativity. It’s a pattern that emerges when we look at the arc of human history.
Some of the greatest leaps in human achievement immediately followed periods of devastating crisis, after mass disruption opened the door to new leaders and new ideas. One example: the Renaissance after the Black Death. Another: the Roaring ’20s, after the First World War and the Spanish flu pandemic. Amid the crisis, people gained a better understanding of the most pressing issues that needed addressing. In the aftermath, those who had adapted to the changed circumstances had the opportunity to introduce new ways of doing things to an audience willing to listen.
Crisis drives creativity
Throughout history, pandemics have thrown society into crisis, disrupting the old way of doing things. Rather than returning to the status quo, the post-pandemic age is characterized by a radical rethink and a shift in power and resources.
Creativity = novelty + value
We’ve shown how creativity can thrive after crisis, and why the conditions are right for it to kick-start Canada’s COVID recovery. The next challenge is to better understand what creativity is, and how to nurture it in young people and across our country’s workforce.
Creativity, in our framework, delivers both novelty and value.
Creativity is an amalgam of skills and abilities that allows us to conceive novel and useful ideas. We’ve seen that through the pandemic, whether it’s healthcare workers or teachers or creative artists, all connecting with people in difficult circumstances, in different and ultimately creative ways.
When learning moved online, Ontario grade three French teacher Steve Massa decided to get creative to keep his students engaged from their kitchen tables. He launched a YouTube channel under the name Monsieur Steve, and took students on virtual field trips around Toronto and as far away as Thunder Bay, incorporating costumes and puppets and his pet cat all in the name of making French grammar fun.
“We have a great need for imagination and creativity to solve the grand challenges—whether these are social problems or healthcare or new technologies. We need creative minds and creative actors to make the world a better place.”
—Dr. Sara Diamond, President Emerita of OCAD University
While we often associate creativity with individuals, organizations, cities and even countries can be creative too. In action, it can mean taking a process from one industry and adapting it to another, like when the U.S. Army studied the logistical and planning methods of the Barnum & Bailey Circus. It can also take the form of coming up with new and practical uses for existing products, like when Nike co-founder Bill Bowerman used a waffle iron to mold a new urethane sole for running shoes.
Increasingly, creativity is acknowledged as a critical economic variable: a competency that can make an individual stand out in his or her field, or that enables a company to dominate, or even create, an industry. If exercised on a larger scale, it can give a society or economy outsized impact on the broader world.
Creativity is bolstered by certain mindsets, and an openness to new perspectives is one of the most important. There is a clear opportunity here for Canada, a country of immigrants, to step up to the plate and get creative.
If we can harness that kind of ambition as a country, Canada—the energy power—could become a creative energy power with ideas that fuel the world.
Most Canadian youth feel confident in their creative skills, but not as much as they do for other 21st century skills.
A survey of 15,000 RBC Future Launch participants found two-thirds (65%) of 15- to 29-year-olds have a high degree of confidence in their creative skills for the workplace. The groundwork for even more creativity is there: they are more comfortable thinking critically (74%), collaborating (73%) and problem solving (70%) than being creative.
Notably, young women have a high degree of confidence to “brainstorm in groups” (74%) compared to young men (64%). Youth not in education or employment (40%) have the lowest comfort in “thinking outside the box.”
This show us that injecting creativity into education specifically would have an outsized impact on the rest of Canada’s key sectors.
Nothing looks quite the same after COVID-19, and that includes the job market. According to our analysis, 21% of Canadians work in roles that require high creative-thinking skills. But that’s now ticking upward, as our appetite for creativity grows.
We’re seeing a greater demand for skills and tools that feed creativity across the labour market. Between the first quarter of 2020 and the first quarter of 2021, employers asked for more creative competencies in job postings, including:
Critical thinking, up 37%
Flexibility, up 20%
Teamwork, up 18%
Ability to learn, up 15%
Continuous improvement, up 12%
Problem solving, up 9%
Strategic thinking, up 8%
Three Canadian sectors in particular are demanding more creativity among new hires: healthcare, education, and sales and service. These sectors have been among the most affected by COVID and are undergoing large-scale transformations that will need creative workers at their core.
Healthcare: Job postings among health occupations are up 36% since February 2020, as demand has spiked for frontline workers and those who can help coordinate Canada’s public health response. Job postings that list creative skills are up 125%, as roles such as healthcare managers (up 79% in Q1 2021) and health diagnostics (up 67% in Q3 2020) need more problem solving, critical thinking and strategic planning to counter the spread of COVID-19.
Education: Job postings in the education field are up 39% since February 2020. Those requiring creative skills spiked by 50% in September 2020 and again by 30% in January 2021, reflecting educators’ need for fresh ideas as new restrictions took hold and online learning expanded. Demand for school administrators has jumped (up 167% in Q1 2021), while education policy and program development roles have grown (up 11% in Q3 2020), with needs for adaptability and continuous improvement driving demand for creative candidates.
Sales and service: Retail job postings overall tumbled during lockdown periods. However, postings explicitly seeking creativity in sales and service increased during these periods, by 14% in April 2020 and 20% in January 2021. Businesses appear to have sought out these skills to help develop new shopping and service models during disruption. Doing things differently was reflected in high growth jobs, including services supervisors (up 24% in Q3 2020) and retail and wholesale buyers (up 18% in Q1 2021), seeking more originality, analytical skills and those with the ability to learn.
In the short term, this means people with high creative skills will enjoy greater mobility and choice of roles. Over the longer term, more Canadians will develop creative skills as workplaces give higher priority to original ideas and critical thought.
Creativity will increasingly be a competitive advantage for individuals, for firms, and even for the country as a whole.
Tomorrow’s creative leaders
There’s only one Elon Musk—and that’s quite all right.
When we think of creative individuals, we often conjure up historic visionaries and inventors, but creativity lives in all of us. It just takes on different forms: in the studio, the laboratory, the classroom and the boardroom.
Through our research, we’ve identified four broad creative archetypes that play different but crucial roles in our society.
The Visionary
This is the Elon Musk category. The Visionary imagines new markets and is willing to take huge risks to bring about change in the world. They build loyal followings, even beyond their own industry, influencing consumer tastes and preferences. The way electric cars have sped from obscurity, to cool, to the dominant trend in the auto industry? That’s the Visionary touch.
The Instigator
This is the sector-specific superhero. The Instigator is able to identify gaps, combine ideas and see opportunities others do not. They can create wholly new products or service offerings, disrupting the sector where they operate. One such example: Canadian tech titan Michele Romanow, whose startup Clearco disrupted the lending market and is now the world’s biggest ecommerce investor.
The Thinker
Drill down a little deeper, and within every workplace, you’ll find the Thinker. This is someone who stands out for their critical thinking, and their adeptness at identifying challenges and coming up with novel ways to address them. In the 1990s, University of Pennsylvania biochemist Katalin Karikó devoted herself to an obscure field: mRNA research. Decades later, her discoveries led to the groundbreaking Moderna and Pfizer vaccines, and turned the tide on COVID.
The Hustler
Need someone to see a new idea through to execution? Call a Hustler. They’re critical to analyzing what is possible, and strategically tweaking the lofty ideas and strategies of the Visionaries and the Instigators. Without the action-oriented Hustler, many ideas might never see the light of day. Apple co-founder Steve Jobs is the Visionary behind the iPhone, but the awe-inspiring camera functions in every new model? Those are thanks to Apple’s 600 camera-hardware technology experts.
“Creativity rests on encouraging yourself to think freely outside of the box, and then working diligently to distill, iterate and ultimately prototype, depending on what the process is.”
—Janet Morrison, President of Sheridan College
How to cultivate creativity
Creativity has always been important, but it matters now, maybe more than ever, as Canada looks beyond the pandemic and into some exciting and scary decades ahead, that will test us as a nation.
Over the last few months, we talked to some of Canada’s most creative people about how they cultivate creativity and what others can learn about maximizing creative potential in individuals and organizations.
Here are four key takeaways:
1. Creativity can be nurtured
Creativity comes naturally to some. It can also be nurtured and developed.
Gil Moore, drummer of the rock band Triumph and founder of Metalworks Institute, differentiated between virtuosos—those who have “explosive growth in their talent and a natural repository of creative juice that just flows”—and the rest of us who have to actually work at it through repetition and gaining skills.
Creativity is known to thrive in the world-famous animation program at Oakville, Ontario’s Sheridan College, but its president, Janet Morrison, is quick to point out the value of teaching creativity across all disciplines. In the college’s business program, students learn creative problem solving: how to clarify the situation, generate ideas, develop and iterate solutions, and implement plans.
Josie Fung, who is tasked with building “future-ready problem solvers” as the executive director of I-THINK at the Rotman School of Management in Toronto, suggested giving students real-world problems to solve, and then the space to do so.
When Parks Canada asked high schoolers at Toronto’s John Polanyi Collegiate Institute to help solve a problem—how to get more people to come to Rouge National Park—the students skipped over ideas like a poster or ad campaign. Instead, they reframed the question, to think about the role of the park in society. This opened up so many more possibilities. They thought: what if the park could be a place for a drug rehabilitation centre? What if it could be a place for mental health therapy? Four years later, Rouge Park struck up a partnership with Blue Door, a nonprofit that provides emergency housing for those experiencing homelessness and crisis, to provide affordable housing using Parks Canada land.
2. Create a culture that embraces the freedom to fail
Shopify—Canada’s most valuable company—embraces failure. You read that right.
“We have built an environment that allows for risk taking, that allows for curiosity and resourcefulness, that allows for reactions,” said Brittany Forsyth, former Chief Talent Officer.
That kind of environment is key, Forsyth said, because creativity isn’t about a lightbulb moment. It’s about coming up with lots of ideas, challenging assumptions and connecting dots, until it unlocks something new: the killer idea that separates you from the competition.
“We give permission to do these key things such as experiment, fail, grow. It’s OK to say you were wrong yesterday and you’re right today, to change your mind.”
—Brittany Forsyth, Shopify’s former Chief Talent Officer
If you look at Cirque du Soleil, ideas can come from every corner of the organization. You need to give employees the space and encouragement to share them.
“We have 5,000 pairs of eyes and ears and we encourage our people to always feed us with something they discovered,” said Daniel Lamarre, the Quebec-based company’s CEO. “Sometimes it might be by reading a book, seeing a new movie and hearing a new piece of music or just seeing something on YouTube or on social media that could be attractive to us.”
Pro tip: Companies can encourage employees to try new things by shaking up the work day, or incorporating such expectations into employee performance goals. Shopify uses “hack days,” where everyone stops what they’re doing and spends three days on a project of their choice, usually coming up with programs or solutions around a specific theme. Over at Google, Gmail was famously created as part of the company’s 20% rule, which allows employees to spend 20% of their time exploring projects that may not deliver immediate dividends but could become big opportunities in the future.
3. Creativity thrives on strategic constraints
It might sound counterintuitive, but limits can actually spur creativity.
“We thought that if we gave students open rein on creating ideas, that would be the way forward,” said Fung, speaking of her work with I-THINK. “And actually, what we heard is that by giving a little more structure, by giving a few more constraints, it actually helped channel their creativity.”
Creative people are comfortable with ambiguity but are also compelled to make sense of it and add their own structure, according to Tom Waller, Chief Science Officer at Vancouver-based Lululemon.
“We very much look for people that are able to sit in ambiguity and go, ‘Hmm, I’m on a blank sheet of paper here, but I’m just going to start doodling if nothing else. And, oh! This doodle turned into something,’” Waller said.
Pro tip: There’s actually a simple three-step way to set up those constraints to drive creativity, according to Ajay Agrawal, head of the University of Toronto’s Creative Destruction Lab. Step one is to establish well-defined goals: what is the problem you’re trying to solve? Step two is ensuring that people have the resources they need, such as time and money, to explore potential solutions. And step three is to recognize and measure success along the way.
4. Creativity is a team sport
The creative engines of the past relied on solo inventors. Leonardo da Vinci, for instance, and other Renaissance thinkers who were polymaths with expertise across multiple areas.
That’s no longer the case, Agrawal said.
“As fields become more and more complex, in order to really understand the frontier of the field, you need to collaborate across multiple people who are experts in different areas.”
“I find that everybody has the potential to play a role in the creative process. It might be a different role, but there is a role for everybody in the creative process.”
—Ajay Agrawal, head of the University of Toronto’s Creative Destruction Lab
This brings us back to our point about creative archetypes: you may have a Visionary or Instigator championing the idea, but you’ll also need a Hustler. The key is to identify what roles are required to produce the best outcomes, and how leaders can help develop the right people and skills for those roles. It may mean casting a wide net to find people from diverse backgrounds and ways of life who are able to contribute their experiences and knowledge. Or thinking about what partnerships can be developed with firms in other sectors, and what opportunities can be generated by reaching out to community organizations.
An age of ideas
As we charge forward into the 2020s, Canada faces some epic challenges. The pandemic highlighted all that is not well within our borders: the broken structure of our long-term care homes, the disproportionate childcare burden on women, racial health and economic disparities, and the challenges of coordinating a country-wide response to an emergency. We cannot look away now. Instead, with fresh eyes, we must embrace the new possibilities that have opened up on a mass scale, including telehealth, remote education, and flexible work arrangements—and the new talent that we could draw in. We are in the early stages of a creative transformation of our economy and society. The COVID crisis, like those that have come before it, shattered our assumptions about how the world works and forced society to embrace experiments and reorganize in a new way. By promoting creativity as a key skill within our schools and workplaces in the post-pandemic world, we can shift into an exciting Age of Ideas that tackles Canada’s most pressing problems.
The Creativity Economy
For more insights on how Canada can weave creativity into its culture, listen to our special two-part series of the Disruptors podcast.
Listen and subscribe to the Disruptors podcast:
About the Authors
Trinh Theresa Do (she goes by Theresa) is responsible for strategy development on the Thought Leadership & Economics team, with occasional forays into podcasting, research, and writing. Previously, she was a strategy advisor to senior management and executives at RBC’s Personal & Commercial Banking business. Prior to joining RBC, Theresa was a national political journalist at CBC News and co-founded a nonprofit that promoted civic engagement through technology innovation.
Sonya Bell joined RBC’s Thought Leadership and Economics team as a Senior Manager, Content Delivery in 2018, coming from Queen’s Park where she was a senior writer to the former Premier of Ontario. Previously, Sonya worked in journalism as a producer at CBC and as a federal political reporter for iPolitics. Between Parliament Hill and Queen’s Park, she spent two seasons as a comedy writer on This Hour Has 22 Minutes.
Andrew Schrumm is a former lead researcher on RBC’s Thought Leadership team, where he examined how Canada can enter the 2020s as a diverse, innovative, and sustainable nation. He managed RBC’s future skills research project on skills-based job mobility, life-long learning, and the potential of automation in our economy.
Black Lives Matter. Greta Thunberg. The Yellow Vests Movement.
Even before COVID hit, a new kind of people power – digitally-enabled, socially-driven – was disrupting the world. Global networks began to overshadow and even sideline governments and institutions.
The trend has only accelerated as our lives have moved even more online, and for Canada it may present a strategic opportunity.
Few countries have as diverse and influential a global network as Canada enjoys through its expats and citizens who live abroad. While there’s no census or formal survey of this growing diaspora, newly published research estimates 2-3 million Canadians live, work or study outside the country.
In the 2020s, this virtual 11th province can become Canada’s super power.
In a world that will be more divided and contentious – there will be yet more need for countries and networks that can bring people together and bridge differences.
Canadians can already be found throughout Hollywood and Nashville, and at top of the business world in New York, London and Hong Kong. They’re at the forefront of global campaigns against war crimes and cybercrimes. They run some of the world’s top universities, including Stanford, Cambridge and Johns Hopkins. And they’re among the most recognized faces on Chinese, British and American television.
Canadians are everywhere.
But unlike most countries, Canada does very little to activate this global population. India has created an Overseas Indians unit, offering special visas and tax incentives to its diaspora. Italy has gone further, as one of eight countries that offers parliamentary representation to expats, while Israel and Singapore maintain active databases and outreach programs for their overseas populations.
As Canada considers a post-COVID world that may be less receptive to government interventions, the opportunity to create new global networks has rarely been more important. They can be a megaphone for our small voice, a connector for our small numbers and a lever for our big ambitions.
A playbook already exists, through the C100 , a non-profit association created in 2010 to bring together Canadians in Silicon Valley. The group has since brought hundreds of Canadian entrepreneurs to the Valley, and connected Valley investors to Canada. It’s also advised both the Harper and Trudeau governments on tax, innovation and immigration policies.
The C100 can become the C1Million, at least in the national imagination, if we pursue a range of low-cost, high-impact policies that follow what other countries are doing:
Create an expat unit at Rideau Hall, under the Governor-General, to speak up for our global population.
Make a five-year budget commitment through Global Affairs Canada to co-fund expat networks.
Build a digital platform, to be administered outside government, for expats to learn about and connect with each other.
Create a national award and pin, in line with the Order of Canada, to be granted annually to overseas Canadians who have represented their country well.
Bring together 50 of our best expats every other summer at Rideau Hall, to meet with government, business, science, media and academic leaders, and explore Canada’s place in the world.
While there are plenty of challenges, the most important may rest with all Canadians – to consider what citizenship means in a digital age.
Canadians have wrestled with the rights and obligations of citizenship since the country was created, and especially since the power of citizenship was transferred from Britain’s overseas office to the government in Ottawa in 1947. A revised citizenship act in 1977 created a more multicultural approach to citizenship, including the option of dual citizenship. But another revision, in 2010, pulled back some of those rights that had been undermined in a less secure, post-9/11 world.
Now, in the 2020s, new ideas of citizenship will continue to emerge as people live, work, study and communicate from anywhere to anywhere. The very notion of “Canadian” may be challenged anew.
We can chart that course with the help of our 11th province, and the Canadians who are already out there, shaping the future of a planet that needs to be a bit more like Canada.
John Stackhouse’s latest book, Planet Canada: How Our Expats Are Shaping the Future, was published in October, 2020 by Random House Canada.
The pandemic has created a historic crisis for Canadian colleges and universities. It could present a significant opportunity, too. The widespread use of online learning platforms and tools offers educators a chance to reach a global body of students that could far exceed Canada’s current market.
It won’t be easy – other countries are eyeing the same opportunity and our schools will need to invest to grow, at a time when they’re being asked to cut. But as Canada pursues a knowledge-driven economic recovery, the digital export of post-secondary education could attract talent, create high-value jobs and help colleges and universities reimagine themselves in a pandemic-disrupted world.
POV
The global spread of COVID-19 shocked international education; and it’s not clear how quickly it will recover. So far this year, just three-quarters of the 2019 level of international students have arrived, while the number of study permit applications has plummeted, risking some of the estimated $22 billion in annual contributions these students make to our economy, and straining a sector that supports an estimated 170,000 jobs.
A concerted effort – among our schools, provinces and federal departments – is needed to resume Canada’s leadership in attracting international students, whose ranks numbered 642,000 at the beginning of 2020. Expedited visa processing, ensuring safe housing and broadening recruitment efforts will be critical.
Yet, international education is also ripe for new models. At the peak of national lockdowns, some 1.6 billion students were pushed out of school, prompting a shift in preferences toward distance and online learning. Among the nearly 300 million new degree-holders we’ll see globally by 2030 – double today’s number – many more will earn their credentials online.
Reaching these potential international students through a hybrid post-secondary model – online at entry, and on-campus at completion – would allow Canada’s universities to be key players in this growing sector. Consider the potential of a collective push among our universities to create a global “Canada U” program. Students would earn credits remotely from their home country, gaining language skills, career guidance and virtual work-integrated learning opportunities – becoming strong candidates to secure admission to upper year studies at a university in Canada.
Key Numbers
The global pandemic slowed student arrivals
Through June 2020, student arrivals among our top-10 source countries fell 26% compared with 2019. More troublesome was the 60% drop in new study permits received by IRCC in April, May and June, and the slow rate of visas processed – only about 10% of last year’s volume was completed this spring.
Yet, internationally mobile learners are motivated to continue studying abroad
COVID lockdowns have discouraged only 5% of international students to fully abandon studies. The majority (54%) are inclined to delay their education by up to 12 months in hopes of starting studies on-campus. Only three in ten plan to begin studying online first.
Number of young graduates set to double by 2030
Asia will produce new graduates at break-neck speed, accounting for more than half of young degree holders over the next decade. The surge will be largely fuelled by China and India, where the number of graduates will grow to 81 million and 70 million respectively.
Global middle class to add 1.7 billion people by 2030
If the COVID recovery is broadly inclusive, the global middle class could swell to 5.7 billion within 10 years, leading to higher post-secondary enrolments, though faculty and funding constraints in the global south may slow institutional growth. India – Canada’s largest source of international students – could see some 600 million move to middle income levels. Meanwhile, Ethiopia, Angola and Cote D’Ivoire could together add over 20 million to the middle class.
Online cross-border education market reaches double global learners
An estimated 13 million students are earning credits online from a foreign institution. This is double the roughly 6 million on-campus international students in 2019. Canada (12%) has been the third most popular destination for on-campus international students, behind the US (21%) and Australia (13%). But it remains a minor player in cross-border online learning.
Key Questions
1. How could an online focus strengthen Canada’s international education strategy?
Online education was absent from Canada’ international education strategy, released in August 2019. Just six months later, the federal government moved quickly to allow foreign students to complete up to 50% of their program online from their home country. While this was intended to shore up existing students amid the pandemic, it opens the possibility of a new approach to our global education engagement.
Canada’s universities have already made significant investments in remote learning methods and technology, having moved 1.4 million students online this spring. Left fragmented, these resources can serve the immediate needs of schools; but combined into a unique international program, they could magnify their reach.
Canada U would engage more students in more places, combining the flexibility of a MOOC, the rigour of a Canadian credential and the appeal of experience in the Canadian workforce. Broadly, here’s what it could include:
Open, rolling enrolment for early-year online studies in their home country.
Lower per-credit tuition costs, driven by the scale of massive global enrolment.
Opportunity to accumulate credits towards a Canadian credential, or transfer to a domestic university.
Canadian based faculty, and remote counsellors for academic, career and language development.
Networking opportunities via Canadian trade offices in their country or satellite campuses.
Chance to undertake remote work-integrated learning (WIL) with a Canadian employer.
Opportunity for admission to on-campus learning at a Canadian school, once student has achieved equivalent credits to 50% of desired program.
Such an approach could open Canadian education to millions of young, mobile learners.
This would be no small undertaking. It would require unprecedented collaboration among our universities to provide course instruction and materials, with supports from federal and provincial governments to build digital infrastructure and global marketing, and among provincial credit transfer bodies to ensure smooth academic transitions.
2. How big is the online education market?
The OECD estimates that over 13 million students participate in cross-border online education, through both formal institutions and online platforms. The majority of these learners – while benefiting from the convenience of online studies – are not putting those credits toward a degree.
The UK has the largest number of remote international students working towards a degree – at 120,000 or about 12% of their enrolled foreign students. The culture of open distant learning (ODL) has been a key part of the UK’s strategy, cultivated across the Commonwealth – with the Open University in the UK claiming more than 2 million global graduates. By contrast, in the US, only about 5% of international students are based outside the country, and at Canada’s largest online-only school, Athabasca University, just 3% are international students.
The most significant growth over the last decade has been among MOOCs, or massive open online courses, that offer short-term courses. Though characterized by low course completions and poor student retention, their use has spiked amid the current economic uncertainty as learners seek to upgrade skills.
One of the largest platforms, EdX, claims to have had 33 million learners – nearly 70% from US and Europe. New entrant Lectera is launching a multi-lingual, fast-training program focused on workplace skills to reach global students. Google is entering this space too, providing fast-track online learning for job-focused skills to compete with traditional college diplomas.
Developed by MIT and Harvard, Edx has successfully bridged MOOC and traditional education with its MicroBachelors and MicroMasters programs, where students from anywhere can earn credits online, fast-tracking their learning when admitted on-campus. The success of these efforts demonstrates the potential for a “Canada U” program.
3. Do international students want to study online?
International students prefer– by far – to study on-campus, when possible. Surveys have repeatedly shown a strong desire among these learners to transition to the Canadian job market, with 70% intending to work here after graduation. Only the reputation of our education system (82%) and perception of a safe, tolerant society (79%) rate higher.
Yet, when we look at those who study primarily online, students in emerging countries appear to have a higher motivation to earn foreign credits online. Among MOOC students in Colombia, Philippines and South Africa, 49% completed at least one course; among those employed, it jumped to 70%, a 2016 survey found. By comparison, only 5 to 10% of MOOC students in the US and Europe will complete their online studies.
A Canada U could achieve a balanced approach of online and on-campus; offering accessible remote learning to many, with a pathway to completing studies at a Canadian school.
4. Where is the demand for greater post-secondary education?
Among Canada’s top originating countries of international students, five have seen enormous growth in high school completion that hasn’t been matched by post-secondary achievement: Vietnam, Brazil, Iran, China and India. Among them, the proportion of adults (over 25) with only a high school diploma jumped between 1990 and 2010.
Upper Secondary education completion among adults (25+) without tertiary education, select countries
This growth shows two things. First, the value of high school completion is rising in developing nations. Second, there has been a slower capacity to convert these learners to post-secondary degrees. It’s no surprise either that the top originating countries of international students are also source countries of new Canadians; last year over 11,000 new permanent residents previously studied here. For Canada, education exports have led directly to talent imports.
Online education can attract more international students than traditional on-campus education by lowering the high financial barriers of tuition, travel and housing. Cost will be a key factor for families arriving into the middle class. This year alone, currency pressures have seen the Canadian dollar appreciate greatly against the Brazilian Real, Nigerian Naira, Ethiopian Birr, Russian Ruble, and slightly against the Indian Rupee and Chinese Yuan – boosting tuition costs.
What to Watch
As colleges and universities reopen, and travel restrictions ease, will applications to study in Canada return to pre-COVID levels? Do we have enough capacity to promptly process applications?
How will universities perceive their new online education resources, as strictly emergency spending or a potential growth opportunity? Can schools collaborate towards more shared online resources?
To appeal to global students, will universities attempt a larger physical presence abroad, through satellite campuses or local partnerships?
How can the intellectual property of online education be secured when entering markets with poor censorship or legal regimes?
Key Stakes
Education is a global social good. It is also a potent global market. The two concepts should not be separated. Canada has an excellent reputation abroad for high quality education; it’s one of the things we do best, with the highest rated tertiary education among the OECD and an already impressive share of international students choosing to learn here.
In the increasingly global knowledge economy, education is one of Canada’s greatest competitive advantages. Our deep alumni network of foreign graduates helps foster business networks abroad and strengthens trading relationships. Our robust student work permits lead to strong talent acquisition as a pathway to permanent residency. As Canada looks to rebuild for the 2020s, international education must be a key plank in our national strategy.
Canada U is one idea to help us get there. Embracing this bold venture will mean breaking down the artificial barriers between our higher education institutions and provinces to promote a collaborative, platform approach to international education. It will also require new funding to assemble the necessary technology, faculty and global marketing to make it a success, without clawing back existing transfers to our universities.
There is no shortage of competition in international education – from traditional universities to tech upstarts to growing domestic higher education – but Canada is uniquely placed to lead (if it wants to).
How the COVID-19 Crisis will Transform Higher Education
This new generation enjoys better access to education and technology than any before, but also faces unique economic barriers as it enters a workforce profoundly disrupted by the COVID-19 pandemic.
For Canada, the potential benefits, and risks, are enormous. The Indigenous population has been growing at four times the rate of the non-Indigenous population, and today more than half of First Nations and Inuit people are under the age of 30. Even before the pandemic, though, their economic pathways were broken. The probabilities of employment for First Nations youth were only 75% (and 87% for Metis), compared to 90% for non-Indigenous people.
This new generation of Indigenous youth will be critical to the economic recovery. The nature of the recovery will also be critical to their prosperity. According to a new study by the Canadian Council of Aboriginal Business and the Diversity Institute of Ryerson University, the Canadian economy stands to gain $27.7 billion through better engagement of Indigenous youth. But not if we follow business as usual.
We know the past decade transformed our economy, and world, through rapid advances in mobile communications, cloud computing and artificial intelligence. We anticipate these technology platforms will become even more powerful, and essential to a post-COVID economy. And as we design and fund policies for the recovery, we need to appreciate how this accelerated change can impact Indigenous youth.
To better understand and inform the choices ahead, RBC’s Thought Leadership group has held a series of roundtables through the crisis, with Indigenous youth, educators and employers, as part of a long-term research initiative. The latest roundtable, on June 23, was co-chaired by RBC CEO Dave McKay and National Chief Perry Bellegarde, to hear from First Nations chiefs and Indigenous business leaders on what their communities and youth need in order to better prepare for a digitally-enabled recovery.
While the group felt self-government remains the greatest challenge — and greatest opportunity for unlocking the economic potential of Indigenous communities — we know this commitment may require years more effort to fulfil. In the meantime, there are several concrete steps Canada can take to position this new generation for success. Here are five actionable ideas that emerged:
1. Strengthen school-to-work linkages
While high school completion rates among Indigenous youth improved significantly between 2006 and 2016, university completion rates worsened compared to non-Indigenous youth. One reason: poor employment for Indigenous students, especially in the service sectors. About 20% of the Indigenous workforce is employed in trades, transportation and equipment operations, compared to about 15% for the non-Indigenous population. By contrast, only 5.5% are employed in management positions, compared to 9% for the non-Indigenous workforce, and the gap is growing.
As employers begin to rebuild and rehire, and governments commit billions to economic reconstruction, creating more workforce linkages for Indigenous students will be critical. This can start with more internships, co-ops and mentorships that cultivate both workplace skills and help youth develop meaningful aspirations. These experiences also create stronger links for youth to local labour markets. This approach to human capital needs to extend further into businesses, too, to ensure better Indigenous representation on corporate boards, participation in collective bargaining and access to training funds that should be part of all development projects.
2. Build connected infrastructure
Most Canadians take connectivity for granted. For Indigenous Canadians, that’s not the case. Nearly half of the status First Nations population lives on reserves, many of which are disconnected from the digital economy. A lack of reliable access to broadband not only limits commercial activity for Indigenous businesses; it constrains access to online learning, telehealth and remote work. The digital infrastructure for remote communities needs to be completed, no later than the federal promise of 2030, and in a way that anticipates future demands on networks.
Indigenous ownership over infrastructure projects — digital, transportation, healthcare or energy — can strengthen the self-sufficiency of communities by providing diversified revenue and long-term employment. Building these connections will be exponentially more important to community prosperity in the post-COVID era where e-commerce is becoming the preference for many consumers, and big employers look to more distributed workforce models.
3. Rethink supply chains through Indigenous procurement
Cross-border disruptions during the COVID lockdowns highlighted vulnerabilities within essential supply chains, particularly healthcare equipment. As public and private sectors consider on-shoring sourcing of these and other goods, there is plenty of opportunity to launch new procurement partnerships with Indigenous firms across Canada.
The capacity to innovate among Indigenous-owned businesses is strong, as evident in how many mobilized to produce personal protective equipment for their communities. Greater integration into corporate procurement also would create better outlets for services-based businesses to grow and diversify, from graphics design and payroll services to engineering and management consulting.
4. Accelerate low-carbon transition
The post-COVID reset will bring sustainable development into clearer focus; considering the triple bottom line of people, planet and profit. Canadians will be looking for better ways of balancing economic development and environmental stewardship. The transition to a low-carbon economy will take a phased approach — particularly in our resource-rich country — and doing so will rely on Indigenous knowledge.
By making the proper investments now in their education and technologies, Indigenous youth can play a central role in developing the green-collar jobs of the 2020s and beyond. Many of them can become the climate experts of tomorrow, if given the chance to both gain traditional land-based training and cultivate skills in advanced technologies.
5. Expand capital-raising capacity
Securing capital has long been a hurdle for Indigenous businesses. While financial institutions have significantly increased capital availability, Indigenous enterprises still do not operate on a level playing field. Increasing access to credit will remain key to financing start-ups and the small business ecosystem that drives the Canadian economy, including in Indigenous communities; doing this well through the economic recovery requires funders to become enablers by engaging within communities and forging two-way communication.
Yet, securing lasting prosperity in Indigenous communities will take bigger, bolder moves. Settling land claims is one channel to do so, while creating a culture of institutional investing is another. Greater access to equity markets will help to create own-source revenue, with shared stakes in successful infrastructure, development and resources. Linking these investments to skill development and succession planning may build inter-generational wealth.
COVID-19 triggered a mass experiment in online education that will have a lasting impact on how and where Canadians learn. The abrupt change poses a fresh challenge for a Canadian higher-education system that was already preparing for an economic future that might look very different.
POV
Over the span of a few weeks in March, Canada’s post-secondary institutions moved more than 2 million students online. The swift transition provided some early lessons: most students can learn from anywhere, and educational institutions have the ability to transform quickly.
As the urgency of managing the crisis shifts to securing Canada’s economic recovery, students looking to gain the skills to compete in the post-COVID world will demand more from digital education. Institutions should seize on this moment to give students and life-long learners greater flexibility in where, when and how they learn.
The higher-education system is about to become more competitive. Nearly every post-secondary institution on the planet has just made significant investments in online tools and methods. For Canada to remain a global education leader that continues to attract the world’s brightest, our institutions will need to differentiate themselves. This starts with cultivating the scale needed to make online leaning profitable; collaborations across the sector could give students more choices and specializations. The next step requires an inclusive approach to alternative learning – either experiential learning or micro-credentials – that gives students flexibility in how and where they obtain academic credits. At the same time, educators will need to integrate the tools of augmented reality and machine learning to personalize education.
Key Findings
Nearly 1.6 billion learners have been affected by national school closures
Amid the pandemic, 91% of the world’s students were displaced from the classroom. In Canada, more than 7 million students had to shift their learning style: 5.1 million in K-12, 1.2 million in universities, and 800,000 in colleges and polytechnics. The 540,000 students completing post-secondary education this year likely completed their programs remotely.
Canadian institutions historically lacked the resources or expertise to fully develop online learning
About 16% of university and 12% of college students learned primarily online in 2019, while more than one-third of undergraduates had at least one course with blended learning. Despite wider usage of online tools, funding and staffing issues have hampered digital education at half of universities and colleges, more so among smaller institutions.
Canada’s advantage in international student attraction is at risk
Digital spending comprised only 2.5% of global education expenditures pre-lockdown
Despite a 14x increase in EdTech venture capital since 2010, digital spending remains a small fraction of education budgets. Pre-crisis forecasts expected spending to reach 4.3% of budgets by 2025. Investment activity has been concentrated in China and the United States. Last year they attracted 52% and 33%, respectively, of digital education investments.
Key Questions
1. Will the explosion of remote-based learning lead to more options for students?
The simple answer is ‘yes.’ The longer schools remain unable to teach the way they used to, the more sticky remote-based learning will become. Students and educators will want to retain the experiences and tools they like.
Post-pandemic, institutions can expect to have a tougher time attracting students. With students realizing they can learn from anywhere, institutions will need to show why their campus experience is different.
Online education has the potential to be a great leveler among institutions. Schools of any size, location or level can provide unique offerings through online education: it is borderless, scalable and untethered to the traditional academic calendar. At the same time, students are looking for job-ready skills for a fast-changing labour market. Online non-degree granting institutions, such as edX, Coursera and Udemy, can create and scale new, skills-focused courses faster than universities. What if a student could get credit for them? Self-directed programs – where students choose from a menu of micro-credentials; online, on-campus or blended learning; and courses from a variety of institutions – may become an option in the not-too-distant future.
We’ll need to expand the traditional boundaries of higher education, with accredited institutions giving more credit for learning in all forms. While some universities are recognizing Massive Open Online Courses (or MOOCs) in their admissions practices, the real friction point will be within the credit transfer system. One example of more flexible learning is South Korea’s Academic Credit Bank (ACBS), where students can complete studies across institutions, based on their own pace and preferences; once they amass sufficient core, general and elective credits, the ACBS will certify their record and the Ministry of Education can issue a degree (without attachment to any individual institution). Such an experience would give students plenty of options in designing their own learning.
2. Which learners are most vulnerable to disruption?
As online education requires both personal digital devices and strong internet connections, students that lack access to either are most vulnerable to losing out.
About one in four Canadian households in lower-income categories use smartphones as their primary internet access. Roughly 10% of households – mostly in rural areas – lack reliable broadband internet. Indigenous students are over-represented in these categories. And for students with accessibility concerns, institutions may need to provide custom digital tools to ensure continuity in their learning.
The current ambiguity of when schools can return to normal operations will influence how some students make decisions with long-term impacts. In any other year, about 40,000 high school students will drop out of studies. This year, we are likely to see higher numbers, as nearly 300,000 are at higher risk of not completing a diploma due to economic insecurity.
For those entering university, college and trades programs this year, orientation is likely to be a remote experience too. Many schools are considering whether to change the timing of first-year courses, including front-loading online-ready courses to the fall, even those that previously had strict pre-requisites. Education consultant Alex Usher has called on Canadian universities to collaborate on a common, online first-year curriculum for 2020 entrants. Given uncertainties around the student experience in 2020/2021, one in four students is considering a gap year or leave of absence, according to recent Ivy Research Council surveys.
3. Will online learning in Canada still appeal to international students?
This remains to be seen, and is a critical question: international students are big business for our schools. If they are unable to enter Canada, we will need to find new ways of marketing a Canadian credential to non-residents.
At the start of 2020, over 640,000 foreign nationals held study permits; while at least 293,000 new permits were issued in 2019 alone, across all learning levels. In post-secondary, the international student population has doubled in the last five years to 500,000, nearly one in four students, contributing about $22 billion in GDP and about 11,000 new permanent residents annually.
Amid lockdowns, new student arrivals dropped in Q1 2020, while severe declines should be expected for the foreseeable future. To stem enrolment declines, the federal government is permitting new international students to begin their programs in their home country, complete up to 50% of their program via distance learning, and assuring access to post-graduate work permits. However, the shift to online learning greatly alters an international student’s experience if they’re unable to reside in Canada during their studies and make connections, while still paying nearly double the tuition of domestic students.
About 26% of study permit holders (or 168,000) come from countries with the most aggressive online censorship regimes. Access to Canadian education resources cannot be guaranteed for this group. Colleges and universities should prepare for a high degree of enrolment deferrals to Winter 2021 or later, and the resulting need to restructure course prerequisites and in-year bridging programs.
Colleges that offer career-transition programs for international students – which have experienced enormous growth in the previous 15 years – could be greatly impacted for two reasons. First, online learning won’t provide the hands-on, workplace-based learning that’s integral for these mostly health care workers or tradespeople. Second, uncertainty of the job market in Canada will dissuade many from taking the risk of relocating.
4. Can job-ready skills be cultivated through online learning?
Without question, learning remotely develops skills that employers demand. It requires students to manage their time effectively, strengthen their written communications and foster a digital aptitude to work alongside technology. And right now, the biggest lessons students are gaining aren’t academic; it’s about being resilient and adaptive. These will be key attributes for their future.
However, the online environment can fall short in developing socio-emotional skills like active listening, speaking and critical thinking skills. RBC’s 2018 report, Humans Wanted, concluded that these skills will be in the highest demand by Canadian employers. Online instruction requires a different pedagogy than in-person learning to achieve the same outcomes, and to develop these human skills it needs to support various forms of social interaction.
Athabasca University, Canada’s largest online-only school, doesn’t try to replicate the classroom in digital form. But it has taken a learner-centered approach to skills development, encouraging peer-to-peer interactions through team-based learning and virtual study groups. Athabasca’s April enrolment grew by 12.3% for undergraduate and 10.7% for graduate studies; an early signal of student preferences in the COVID-19 era.
Work integrated learning (or WIL) has become a part of studies for nearly 60% of post-secondary students, as it cultivates workplace skills and professional networks that can facilitate smoother transitions to employment. The lockdown has made these opportunities impossible for many employers; about one-third of students have lost or delayed their WIL placement. Virtual WIL has been an alternative for some students, and this format may stick around. Vancouver-based Riipen Networks, which creates short-term, virtual work projects for students, has now engaged with 45,000 students across 200 schools in North America. For coops, Canadian university administrators (via CEWIL) have ensured that students will receive credit for such Virtual WIL projects.
5. Can learning on a massive scale become more personalized?
If it can’t, students are more likely to disengage. While online learning requires scale to be profitable – such as classes of hundreds or thousands of students – it must offer learners personalized experiences.
The market for EdTech is as hot as it’s ever been, with VC activity reaching US$3 billion in Q1 2020, or about the entire value of deals in all of 2016. In highest demand are the tools that promise to make the digital experience unique for each learner. Augmented and virtual reality are being used to replace live subjects (e.g. nursing, dental) or to provide access to expensive test equipment (e.g. machine repair, construction). These tools allow students to practice and explore in new environments without risk of harm or error. EdTech market watcher HolonIQ is most optimistic on AR/VR, predicting a 7x increase in spending by 2025. Adapted for smartphones, these tools could usher in a new wave of remote learning including to virtual laboratories and situation-based learning that may be impossible in a physical environment.
Artificial intelligence will be a huge disruptor for education in the 2020s. While chat-bot tutors might reduce demands on faculty and real-time translators could break down language barriers, machine learning has the potential to completely alter student assessments. By understanding and documenting a student’s progress through digital-based learning, AI can develop customized learning plans. Applied broadly, these tools could eliminate aged-based grade levels in K-12 or change course pre-requisites to skill requirements for progression in post-secondary.
The infrastructure of education may be transformed too by blockchain technology, where credentials could be instantly verified. Such a system could lead to simplified credit transfers between institutions and stacking of credentials. This could open the possibility of a personal skills registry, where one’s skills, credentials and ongoing learning achievements are certified and accessible.
6. Are post-secondary institutions at an inflection point for their business model?
COVID-19 may precipitate the largest pivot in the delivery of higher education we’ve ever seen. Enrolment and revenue declines, combined with increased costs in technology, will force institutions to innovate. Those that can’t will be left behind.
First, we cannot ignore the transformation schools made to get over 2 million learners online in March. This is a major achievement, considering nearly two-thirds of Canadian post-secondary institutions cited faculty resistance as the main barrier to providing more online course options prior to COVID-19. Many educators believed online delivery limited outcomes, primarily that students were unable to self-regulate their learning. Any of these misgivings have given way – at least temporarily – to emergency measures, and institutions have been making strides on technology and course design.
Second, the institutions that had previously invested in online education are best positioned to pivot their operations. Université de Laval initiated its own learning platform in the late-2000s, through the Laval Academy of Digital Transformation; prior to COVID, 71% of its courses did not have an online component, but by end of March 95% of its courses transitioned to the online platform. At the University of Windsor, the Office of Open Learning quickly deployed resources and training for faculty to go “online in a hurry”. Bite-sized training through templates, tools, as well as blogs and podcasts, were shared across institutions. The University of Waterloo has hired over 300 summer students to work with faculty to transition courses online for fall 2020.
Finally, we will see a breakdown of the artificial barriers between Canada’s higher-education institutions. Many of which are already facing pressures to reduce costs, amid soaring public debts and expected enrolment declines. Stronger collaborations between universities and colleges will be needed to reduce duplication of and increase access to online resources. Sharing of course and learning materials is already practiced by the Maple League of schools in Atlantic Canada, the Tri-University Group in southern Ontario, and through Education City in Ottawa. Going forward, these types of partnerships will be necessary to coordinate online course offerings that maximize student options and experiences.
What we’re watching:
Canada’s higher education system has an opportunity to transform, to become a global player in online education, even in a post-pandemic world. To differentiate itself, things to consider:
Collaborations among universities, colleges and polytechnics on common digital learning platforms, as well as shared online curricula.
Proposals to modernize the credit transfer system that recognize micro-credentials and experiential learning completions towards a diploma or degree.
Changes to the traditional academic calendar, with higher enrolments in spring/summer terms, as well as rolling start dates for online students.
New forms of engagement with international students that may include more in-country presence of Canadian institutions.
Greater demand for course designers to develop pedagogy that adds AR/VR and machine learning to create personalized student experiences.
To learn more about how Canada can leverage its strength in education to become a global player in online learning, listen to our podcast episode.
How the COVID-19 Crisis will Transform Higher Education
As our neighbour to the south grows increasingly insular, Canada has gone the opposite way – welcoming newcomers, which has led to a boom in our tech industry. Toronto had the biggest growth of technology jobs of any North American city between 2013 and 2018. Vancouver also placed top five.
Today, roughly 40% of Canadian tech workers are immigrants. And thanks to the Global Talent Stream fast-track immigration program, Canada has brought in nearly 24,000 high-tech workers since 2017.
But the COVID crisis has disrupted the very core of immigration – the movement of people. Canada will need to think about how to maintain the momentum we’ve built to jump over the hurdles of protectionism and continued border closures to connect with the world.
TribalScale, a Toronto-based digital consultancy, is among the many Canadian tech companies with relationships across the globe. It’s played a unique role by helping hundreds of new Canadians launch lives here and by exporting Canadian intellectual property to markets from Southern California to the Persian Gulf. TribalScale’s founder and CEO Sheetal Jaitly and senior product designer Eman Faiz joined the RBC Disruptors podcast to talk about Canadian tech talent – both within our country and abroad – in a post-COVID economy.
“Our Canadian ecosystem is really built around universities, where we attract some top talent around the world to come here and study,” Jaitly said. TribalScale has recruited from across the country and sponsored international students studying in Canada who were looking to get into the workforce.
“It was very much a merit-based system where you could attract some of the smartest talent in the world to come fill the jobs that are pretty scarce in technology.”
But consider the flip side. Elevating Canadian expertise on the world stage is equally as important as bringing talent in.
“We are super strong in the areas of AI, robotics, automation,” Jaitly said. “These are all things that the entire globe now is going to need.”
“It’s a huge moment for us Canadians.”
So, as we navigate the future and all the challenges it poses, here are five key points for Canadian tech organizations to consider.
1. Human-centred design thinking is crucial. In earlier years, most of us thought of design as prescriptive, even technical. But really it’s about solving problems. It’s a mindset that keeps teams creative and agile in the face of problems and constantly looking for data-driven solutions. Even those of us who aren’t designers can benefit from design thinking, which at its core focuses on adapting to customer and end user needs.
2. Universities and colleges are Canada’s talent magnets. We’re home to some of the world’s best schools. And every year, they attract hundreds of thousands of aspiring and ambitious youth. We need to think critically and creatively about how we can use this to our benefit and take advantage of global talent that’s already living, studying and growing in Canada.
3. Remote work culture is here to stay. Unfortunately, some of the companies that were hardest hit by the COVID crisis were the ones that were not set up to thrive in a digital environment. We’ve learned many companies can function with remote working cultures and many other companies need to adapt to remote culture so they don’t get left behind. Your future employees and customers will expect it.
4. Corporate purpose – we’re seeing it everywhere. Organizations with a clear purpose and vision are better positioned to withstand enormous shocks like COVID. It sees them through tough times and tough decisions. So as we struggle through the months ahead, be open and honest about the company you’re trying to build and the kind of values and attitudes that will get you there.
5. Mindset. Hard and soft skills are important, but the right mindset can be even more valuable. Invest in team members who are not only proactive and solutions-oriented, but open to and even excited by change. To succeed, we need to learn to thrive in any environment.
As we move forward with rebuilding our economy, it’s important that we understand the value of the right tools, the right team and the right way of thinking. That way, Canadians and Canadian companies can continue to grow, thrive and innovate.
In a new Gallup survey for Northeastern University, 61% of Canadians and 71% of Americans think artificial intelligence will eliminate more jobs than it creates. Roughly half of those respondents think AI will also decrease the number of good jobs out there.
But the vast majority also think they’re immune to automation.
Despite a general concern about the impact of AI, only 37% of Canadians and 17% of Americans think their job will be eliminated because of smart technologies.
The Gallup results were presented at a recent Future of Work discussion at Northeastern’s Toronto campus, put on by the Ontario Chamber of Commerce and RBC.
Helena Gottschling, RBC’s global head of human resources, told the forum that in financial services, automation is leading to new and different jobs – and a changing mix of skills – which means an ever-growing need for lifelong learning.
More than half of RBC’s 55,000 Canadian employees are enrolled in a digital learning program, often offered in the form of mobile and modular programs for skills ranging from digital troubleshooting to communications.
In the Gallup survey, 92% of Canadians (and 95% of Americans) said they want some form of ongoing learning through their careers – not surprising given that two thirds of them worry their skills will be outdated within a decade.
Despite those worries, few know what skills they’ll need to thrive in an AI-powered economy, but there was strong agreement across Canada, the U.S. and Britain that people will need so-called soft skills like teamwork, communication, creativity and critical thinking.
Gottschling agreed with that assessment, saying “the shelf life of tech skills will be shorter, while the shelf life of human skills will be just as long.”
A greater concern in the study was a lack of confidence in universities — for Canadians as well as American and Britons – to prepare graduates for the jobs of tomorrow. A rating of high confidence was lowest (3%) in the U.S.
A plurality of respondents viewed employers as best-equipped to provide career-long education and training.
Gottschling said most employees need solutions that are affordable, time-efficient and relevant to their ambitions. And then there’s mindset. Do people have the will and skill to learn?
The decade is wrapping up with a very different kind of championship held in the same arena. The Dota 2 tournament — the Super Bowl of electronic gaming — in Vancouver’s Rogers Arena and ensuing launch of a local pro esports team are just the latest indications of how much society, and the skills economy, can move in a decade.
From goal scorer to global gamer.
Few might have predicted such a change, or the massive surge in software jobs driven by gaming, social media and on-demand services. And yet, in the past decade, software publishing jobs have gone from 31,000 to 50,000, while jobs in computer systems design have grown from 155,000 to 258,000. The video gaming industry says it now accounts for 48,000 full-time equivalent jobs, with growth of more than 10% a year.
The skills revolution brought on by everything from gaming to the gig economy is just one reason most provinces are reviewing every level of education, as governments grapple with the ongoing challenge of people without jobs and jobs without people.
I was part of a panel discussion on the subject at the Canadian Club of Toronto, to explore how post-secondary education can better prepare students for a rapidly changing world of work.
Anne Sado, President of Toronto’s George Brown College, said we need to:
Make learning highly personalized, as students have very different needs.
Mix the classroom with digital and experiential learning.
Connect the curriculum with industry and community.
Set the stage for life-long learning.
Make resilience the fourth R.
Ross Romano, Ontario’s post-secondary Education Minister, stressed the need to connect research with commercial opportunities. It’s not only about driving economic value from campuses; it’s about building an innovation economy between employers, entrepreneurs and educators.
I told the audience we can expect three trends in the 2020s:
More educators entering the market, as demand grows for lifelong learning.
More individuals focused on skills training. Think of how we approach fitness.
More educators competing for that demand, and coming up with more creative and convenient approaches to teaching. Perhaps a Netflix for learning, with device-based, on-demand, shareable and snackable lessons.
I recently led a roundtable of employers to discuss what the elementary and secondary school systems might consider to better prepare youth for those challenges. The group included some of Canada’s biggest companies, trade unions, non-profits, small business representatives and public sector organizations.
Here’s what they said we need:
More computational thinking. We don’t need a nation of coders; we do need a generation who think like coders.
More digital design thinking, with students focused on problem solving, teamwork, iterative work models and data-driven solutions. “It’s a mindset,” one employer said.
New ways to connect teachers to practitioners.
Gen C skills: compassion, communication, collaboration, complex problem solving and critical thinking. They’re the skills most in demand, not least because of the ongoing boom in healthcare.
Entrepreneurship. Even large organizations need more of those basic skills.
Trades. Most of Canada is facing a critical shortage. Schools need to get students — and parents — thinking more seriously about it.
Work-integrated learning. More co-ops, internships and apprenticeships, starting in high school. It’s not only good for the student; it injects organizations with fresh thinking and new energy.
Learning to learn. Students need to be taught to become better problem solvers and approach challenges in new ways.
Partnerships. No one sector or educator can address the skills shortage alone. Yet a failure to address those shortages will hurt economic productivity for all.
But in a workforce buffeted by technological change, healthcare has an advantage.
Due to the profoundly human nature of the work, advanced technologies don’t pose a significant threat to the physicians, nurses, therapists and others who provide all manner of care to Canadians. Automation will create efficiencies and replace some work, but don’t expect a robot to deliver a cancer diagnosis or replace hands-on homecare anytime soon.
That’s a welcome prognosis, but Canada’s healthcare sector is facing a critical test. The country’s aging population is poised to become a silver tsunami that will add another $120 billion in healthcare costs over the next decade. To harness the full power of technology in a country where one in four people will be seniors, the sector will need to embrace new ways of working.
According to Paging Dr. Data, a new RBC report, around 17% of occupations in the healthcare sector face a risk from automation—half the level faced by the workforce as a whole.
The sector’s robust job creation is also set to continue: there will be 370,000 job openings by 2025, and the sector will be short of workers under even the most optimistic of projections. The shortfall offers a potential career path for workers displaced in other sectors, many of whom already have some of the core skills sought in healthcare.
Which brings us to the reskilling challenge. Canada’s healthcare system needs to up its skills game, and fast. Workers hoping to make the leap into healthcare will need the time, funds, and external support to prepare for a career switch. Those already in the sector will need to retrain for disruptive technologies. And the sector will be looking for entirely new skills too. Think wearable-device coding and 3D printing design.
In a sea of specialists, our research revealed some themes in terms of skills needed: digital fluency (the ability to interact with and analyze data, not just collect it), an ability to deliver virtual care (as telemedicine expands), and navigational skills (to assist patients’ journey through an increasingly complex health system). Finally, the human skills at the core of the best healthcare—empathy, active listening, critical thinking and complex problem-solving—will be more important than ever.
The skills revolution is already happening in healthcare. Educators are adapting courses from other disciplines, and training for adaptability and resiliency. Doctors are talking to AI specialists about how they can build algorithms to improve care. Hospitals are adopting some of the state-of-the-art technology, enabling them to attract new talent.
Properly designed, a mix of technology, skills and innovative management can help Canada prepare for the silver tsunami. We still have time to get it right. But there’s a particular urgency to making the skills economy work for healthcare.
To learn more about the impending silver tsunami and its implications on Canada’s healthcare sector, listen to our podcast episode, Solving for the Silver Tsunami.