RBC Financial Group
RBC Home | Search | Site Map | Contact Us | Legal Terms | Français  
Other RBC Sites:
Banking Investments Insurance Capital Markets
» Corporate Profile
» Corporate Governance
» History
» Investor Relations
» Media Newsroom
» Economics
» Publications
» Corporate Responsibility
» Careers
» Donations
» Sponsorships
» The Environment
» Become a Vendor
» Become an Employee
Make a Complaint
 Making a Complaint
 Office of the Ombudsman
  Helping Clients Make Informed Decisions
  Case Studies
  Annual Report

Case Studies

 

Misunderstandings escalate service-charge problem

The Problem

Case study:
 
What can be learned - the expert's advice
 

From the Client's Perspective

When a RBC client received a replacement Gold Client Card in the mail, the accompanying letter said that her Gold Client Card entitled her to free in-branch bill payments. Yet, the client had been charged service fees for the payments over a period of several years. The client asked for reimbursement of the fees. When the branch refused to reimburse her for what it believed were valid fees, the client wrote to RBC Financial Group's Customer Relations Centre. The bank wrote back, saying the charges were valid and she was not entitled to reimbursement. The client approached the Ombudsman.

From Royal Bank's perspective

For varying costs, customers may select from among a number of flat-fee banking packages - including those that waive service fees for in-branch bill payments.* Since the customer did not subscribe to a package, the branch believed it was correct in not waiving service fees for in-branch bill payments. For the same reason, the RBC Financial Group Customer Relations Centre agreed with the branch's position.

* For reasons unrelated to this case, RBC removed the fee for in-branch bill payments in the year 2000 during its regular review of product and service fees. The purpose of this case study is to illustrate the importance of effective listening.

The Resolution

The Office of the Ombudsman reports

"We spoke with the client and clarified the unresolved issue. It became apparent there was a misunderstanding on the bank's part.

Our fact-finding revealed that the branch did not realize that the customer was entitled to a waiver of the service fee simply because she had a Gold Client Card. There are very few customers with Gold Client Cards who do not also have a banking package that already waives fees for in-branch bill payments. As it turned out, the bank did not understand the nature of the complaint.

We contacted the client's area manager. He immediately arranged for the customer to be reimbursed for the service fees she had been incorrectly charged, and informed the branch of their error.


What can be learned: the expert's advice

For RBC
Understand that some clients may have unusual circumstances that affect their banking package entitlements. Take the time to verify all account and card features, especially when concerns about fees arise.

If you can't resolve a complaint to the client's satisfaction personally, make sure you link the client with a more senior person in your area; that person may have the necessary knowledge or authority.

When a customer complains, really listen for the intended message. Ask questions. Don't assume. In this case, by the time the bank responded in writing to the customer, not only had it missed her point, it had lost the opportunity to resolve the problem directly with her.

Avoid misunderstandings. Make a quick call to the customer before, or instead of, writing a letter.

For clients
Keeping yourself informed about bank services and your specific privileges pays off.

Make sure you question service fees that do not make sense as soon as possible.

If your efforts to resolve your concern at the source do not work, then ask to speak to a more senior manager. Most problems can be addressed by the branch or area manager. If there is still no resolution, then move on to the RBC Financial Group Customer Relations Centre or, finally, the Office of the Ombudsman.

Please note: The above case study was chosen because of the significance of the learning derived from it. It is not an attempt to duplicate the demographics of the case by issue, outcome, RBC Financial Group or any other factors.

Photograph does not depict actual customer.


 

Take Action
  Report a fraudulent email or other security concern
  Make a Complaint
11/22/2007 07:36:30